| Name | Map Tool Token Link | Type |
|---|---|---|
| Pegasus | |
Magical Beast |
| Phantom Fungus | |
Plant |
| Phase Spider | |
Magical Beast |
| Phase Wasp | RPTok | Magical Beast |
| Phasm | |
Aberration |
| Phisarazu | RPTok | Outsider |
| Phoenix | RPTok | Magical Beast |
| Phthisic | RPTok | Monstrous Humanoid |
| 1st-Level Warrior Aasimar | |
Outsider |
| 1st-Level Warrior Chaond | |
Warrior |
| 1st-Level Warrior Tiefling | RPTok | Outsider |
| 1st-Level Warrior Zenythri | |
Warrior |
| Pony | RPTok | Animal |
| War Pony | RPTok | Animal |
| Porpoise | RPTok | Animal |
| Prismasaurus | RPTok | Magical Beast |
| Pseudodragon | |
Dragon |
| Pseudonatural Troll | RPTok | Outsider |
| Psicrystal | RPTok | Construct |
| Psion-Killer | RPTok | Construct |
| Average Psurlon | |
Aberration |
| Giant Psurlon | |
Aberration |
| Elder Psurlon | |
Aberration |
| Puppeteer | RPTok | Magical Beast |
| Flesh Harrower Puppeteer | RPTok | Magical Beast |
| Purple Worm | |
Magical Beast |